This was written by Rami Kaminski, MD, founder and director of the Institute for Integrative Psychiatry in New York City.
Why I Am a Bad Jew
For centuries, we lived in Berdichev. In the brutal Ukrainian winter of 1941, SS soldiers arrived there and rounded up eighty-seven members of my family - babies, young adults, octogenarians - stripped them naked, marched them to a nearby ditch, and executed them. Their lifeless bodies fell silently into a mass grave.
Like most Jews in Europe, my family "cooperated" with the Final Solution. They did not resist or fight back. Six million Jews were slaughtered in a period of four years. They received little sympathy while they were still alive and hunted down like animals. There was no public outcry because the Holocaust fit the world's narrative for Jews during the past 2000 years: a people destined to be persecuted and slaughtered.
During their two millennia in the Diaspora, Jews were not known to resist. There are few recorded instances in which Jews turned against their host nations or retaliated against their murderers. Instead, the survivors - if there were any - were expelled or left for another place. The murdered were regarded as "good" Jews. They accepted their fate helplessly, without resistance.
This narrative of the Jews has played out on the historical stage with boring monotony: Jews get killed because they are Jews. Nothing novel about it. After the Holocaust, however, the world, disgusted by this particularly ghoulish period of history, accorded some sympathy for the Jews.
Media commentary about the ongoing Gaza War reveals the world has now reverted to its pre-Holocaust perspective. Today, the only good Jew is a powerless Jew willing to become a dead one. The Zionist Revolution is to blame. It changed everything. Jews re-created their own country. The Arabs attacked the new Jewish state the day after independence and promised to complete Hitler's genocide. In succeeding decades, the Arabs attacked again and again. Strangely, the Jews, many of them refugees from Arab nations, adopted a surprising, new tactic: they fought back.
With Zionism, the Jews stubbornly refused to follow the centuries-old script. They refuse to be killed without resistance. As a result, the world has become increasingly enraged at their impertinence.
The recent events in Gaza and Mumbai make this plain. In 2005, Israel eliminated all Jewish presence in Gaza making it "Judenrein," and handed it over to the Palestinians. Left behind were synagogues and thriving green houses. The Arabs looted and destroyed them literally the day after Israel's withdrawal was complete. Where these structures once stood, the Palestinians built military bases and installed rocket launchers to shell Israeli civilians. To date, some 7,000 missiles have fallen on Israeli cities and towns, killing and maiming dozens, and sowing widespread terror. Medical studies reveal nearly all Jewish children in the communities bordering Gaza suffer from serious, trauma-induced illness.
The Gazan Palestinians then elected Hamas to lead them. Hamas proceeded to kill or imprison their political rivals, and its leaders, true to the Hamas charter, were unabashed in clearly stating their aims: they will not stop until they achieve their Final Solution, kill all the Jews, take over the land of Israel, and establish a theocracy governed by Islamic law.
As killing Jews for being Jews has been a national sport for centuries, Islamic militants are justified in believing they are merely fulfilling historical tradition in Argentina, India and Gaza. Surely the Jews in Mumbai did not occupy Gaza. They were tortured and killed just for being Jews. And predictably, in the eyes of the world, they immediately became good Jews, just like my murdered family in Bertishev.
Good Jews would wait until Hamas has weapons enabling its members to achieve their ultimate goal of absolute mass murder. Those enraged by Israel's defensive military action insist Hamas uses only "crude" rockets, as if Qassams were BB guns, and military inferiority were somehow equivalent with moral superiority. In fact, Hamas now has Iranian-supplied Grad missiles which have landed on Be'er Sheva and the outskirts of Tel Aviv.
Westerners have had only sporadic exposure to the indiscriminant killing in the name of "holy war" which Israel has lived with for years. Memories of 9-11, Madrid, and London have dimmed. This is not because the Islamic militants made a careful choice of weapons. They simply have not yet acquired nuclear bombs. Once they do, the West will develop a less detached view about the Islamists' professed intentions for the "infidels."
The only enlightened people in the civilized world who actually get it are the Israelis. They've not had time for detached philosophical ponderings. They've been too busy confronting the reality of Islamic fundamentalism.
Soon, Iran will have nuclear weapons. It will give them to Hezbollah and Hamas. Today, Jews must take a position: either be "good" Jews willing to be slaughtered without resistance, or be "bad" Jews who defend themselves at the cost of being pariahs of our enlightened world. Good Jews would wait for another six million to be murdered, and pick up to leave for another country to start the cycle again. The bad ones refuse to go calmly into the ditch.
I confess: I'm a bad Jew.
Rami Kaminski, MD, is Director and Founder of the Institute for Integrative Psychiatry in New York, a not-for-profit organization aimed at evaluating current psychiatric services and how they integrate with medicine, such as the mutual effects between medical and psychiatric conditions. Prior to that, Dr. Kaminkski was the Commissioner's Liaison to Families and Community and Medical Director of Operations at the New York State Office of Mental Health. Dr. Kaminski also holds an academic position as Associate Professor of Psychiatry at Columbia University. He earned recognition in 1990 from Mt. Sinai Hospital as Physician of the Year, and received the Exemplary Psychiatrist Awards from the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill. Dr. Kaminski's research explores neuropsychiatric aspects of brain disorders, such as Alzheimer and Parkinson's disease and movement disorders, as well as psychopharmacology of schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders. He was for many years Director of The Schizophrenia research Unit at Mount Sinai Hospital in NYC. Dr. Kaminiski also served as the Medical Director of the PMHP and consultant to the committee in charge of developing the Special Needs Program.
I can only wonder how many "bad Jews" exist today. -rebbele
Sunday, January 18, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Dr Kaminski is a "bad" Jew because he isn't sufficiently aware of Jewish history and the proud record of Jewish military achievements. His theme that "good"jews go quietly to their deaths is wrong, non-factual and stupid!
First, my family on my mother's side came from Medzhibozh, in the Letichev District of the Ukraine, and my mother's family was wiped out by the Nazis. My credentials are as good as Dr Kaminski's and perhaps better. No one that I ever heard referred to Jewish victims as "good" Jews because they agreed to be slaughtered.
From information that we are getting now, we know that there were rebellions in some of the death camps, like Sobibor, and we know about the Bielski brothers who saved 1200 Jews and fought the Nazis.
From Biblical times until today, Jews have fought foes, while signifcantly out numbered and won or died gloriously.
Dr. Kaminski, have you not heard about the Maccabees, a Jewish group of guerillas, led by Priests, who defeated Antiochus the 4th and the Assyrian Army in the year 161 BCE and reconsecrated Solomon's Temple? Are you not aware that the City of Jerusalem held off the Roman Army for 4 years before falling in the year 70, and a group of Jewish Zealots who escaped from Jerusalem held off the Roman Army for another 3 years at Masada and then committed suicide rather than being conquered in the year 73?
Some 60 years later the Jews revolted against Rome again under Bar Kochba and fought for 3 years until their defeat in year 135. The Romans were so upset with the Jewish revolt -- the fiercest and longest revolt faced by the Roman Empire, that they destroyed Jerusalem and rebuilt it as a Roman City which they called Aelia Capitolina, which we call Palestine and which those Arabs from Jordan and Egypt are trying to identify themselves with.
In world War II, Poland fell in 2 weeks, the Warsaw Ghetto manned by civilian Jews held off the Nazis for over a month, from mid April to mid May of 1943.
Surely you know that shortly after Ben Gurion accepted the UN Mandate for the establishment of Israel in !947, they were attacked by 5 Muslim Nations and won. Israel was attacked on the same day it gained its independence – May 14th, 1948. The armies of Egypt, Lebanon, Syria and Iraq attacked Israel. Later Jordan joined the fighting. With such a combined force attacking Israel, few would have given the new country any chance of survival, but the Jewish State won. The Jewish State won again against Egypt, Jordan and Syria in 1967 and 1972.
I resent your giving credence to falsehoods that Jews were cowards, who submissively went to their deaths. Jews did what they could under terrible circumstances. Yes, many Jews stripped of their clothes, and under the supervision of Nazi soldiers with automatic weapons and attack dogs, walked with their families into the gas chambers. Under these circumstances what would you have done "bad" Jew?
But Jewish history, including Israel's fight today, a state of 12 million Jews, mandated by the United Nations, dealing with a hostile Muslim population of 1.2 billion, is a proud history. At least I'm very proud of Jewish history and proud of being a "Jew"!
Furthermore, If I were you I would pay no attention to those who would work to destroy Israel through politics, since the Arabs have been unable to do it through war. Let people know the truth! Stand up for Israel as a "Proud" Jew!
Gilbert Skopp
Post a Comment